PropagandaScope

Research preview · Shared text

Which papers published similar text on the same day?

Tianjin Daily and Jilin Daily published the same Xinhua text on 8 October 2026.

Tianjin Daily 天津日报

铸就社会主义文化新辉煌

新思想指导新实践,新思想引领新征程。

新华社北京10月7日电

View original article — Tianjin Daily

Jilin Daily 吉林日报

铸就社会主义文化新辉煌

新思想指导新实践,新思想引领新征程。

新华社北京10月7日电

View original article — Jilin Daily

The short passage above is identical in both records. After text normalization, their stored bodies also match in full. Both name Xinhua as the source.

Shared text does not establish a government instruction. This example cannot explain why the newspapers published it.

The seven-day experiment: data and limits

From 6–12 October 2026, 582 of 4,778 eligible article records (12.18%) had a similar body in another paper on the same issue date. These are algorithmic candidates, not a measure of government-authored news.

The sample has 24–25 newspapers a day. From 5,619 usable records, we excluded 161 known cut bodies, 676 bodies with fewer than 200 normalized characters, and 4 same-paper, same-day identical bodies. Different papers and dates remain separate.

We compared sets of seven-character fragments after Unicode normalization and lowercasing, keeping only letters and digits, including Chinese characters. A cosine score of at least 0.6 flags a same-day, cross-paper pair; each matched record counts once. This is a different method from the original study’s word trigrams.

Some bodies are excerpts or contain page navigation. A missing cut flag does not guarantee a complete article. The dates include the end of the National Day holiday, and coverage changes by day. The candidate share is not a national estimate.

AI-assisted close reading examined twelve pairs selected across similarity levels. This was a small diagnostic check, not independent human validation; accuracy and missed matches remain unmeasured. The example above was checked against the stored records. Original links are supplied for inspection; their current availability was not checked.

Inspired by Waight, Yuan, Roberts and Stewart (2025). Their study used additional evidence to identify government scripting and examine long-term change. This experiment does not reproduce that result.

Waight et al. (2025). The decade-long growth of government-authored news media in China under Xi Jinping

Source: PropagandaScope. Data to 12 October 2026. Exploratory case prepared 13 October 2026.

← All data cards